Why can’t young people afford a place to live?
Housing prices are part of the answer. The other part gets less attention: the cheapest places were made illegal.
A century ago, a lot of people started out in a city by renting a single room. Shared kitchen, shared bath, low rent. It was how a new arrival, a young worker, or someone between jobs got a foothold near the work. These buildings are called single room occupancy housing, or SROs. Today you’ll hear the modern version called co-living.
We sat down with Sam Hooper to talk about what happened to them. Sam is a legislative attorney who works with state lawmakers on zoning and property rights. He wrote the ROOM Act, a model bill that makes it legal again to rent a room with a shared kitchen or bathroom.
What your first place really needed
Think about your first place. How much of it did you really need? A college dorm is a single room with a shared bathroom, and most of us did fine in one.
Sam has a personal version of this. He met his wife in a co-living building in London. The building had flats of four and five rooms, plus a shared gym, a movie room, and a games room. He was early in his career and couldn’t afford a full apartment in an expensive city, but he wanted to live where the jobs were. The market gave him an option that fit.
In America, Sam says, modern zoning has no category for that kind of housing. So it mostly doesn’t get built.
How the rooms went away
Starting around the 1950s, cities decided this kind of housing was blighted. Some of the buildings did have real problems. Sam’s point is that instead of fixing them, cities wrote rules that made the whole category hard to keep:
Zoning turned renting a room into a special permit. You had to ask the city for permission instead of just doing it.
Building codes started treating a shared kitchen like a commercial kitchen, which is expensive to build.
Some places required operable windows, guest registers, and cameras. Sam described one city that made landlords post a phone number outside for neighbors to report residents.
Occupancy limits capped how many unrelated people could live in one house.
Landlords found it easier to convert those buildings into studios and one-bedrooms, or tear them down. The rooms went away.
What losing the bottom rung does
Sam’s argument is that when you remove the bottom rung of the housing ladder, people don’t move up into a nice apartment. They double up, move away, or end up on the street. In his words, no one should be forced to sleep on the street to spare them the indignity of sharing a kitchen.
For young people, he says it also pushes back the big life steps. A first place near a good job costs more than it should, so people live with their parents longer, commute from far out, or skip the opportunity. That delays building equity, getting married, and starting a family.
He also makes a point about homelessness prevention. A cheap room can be the difference between a rough patch and a long stretch on the street. He argues it costs far less to stop someone from falling into street homelessness than to help them out afterward, and that a market can supply those rooms without new government spending.
Empty office buildings
Sam says converting underused office buildings into rooms can work with little or no subsidy. What gets in the way is the same set of rules: zoning that doesn’t allow housing downtown, building code requirements written for hotels, and city ordinances aimed at boarding houses. He thinks cities should let owners convert by right and loosen the codes that don’t help safety.
Boomers in the Comment Section
We always ask Sam the objections that show up whenever we post about this.
“These were fire traps.” Sam says old buildings burn more, and the answer is letting new ones be built and converted under modern safety rules.
“This brings back skid row.” He says skid row is what’s left when only the bottom, unregulated end of the market survives. Legal housing at a range of prices prevents that.
“I don’t want this next door.” Sam points to his own years in a co-living building. He was a young professional building a career, and he expects most residents would be.
“Greedy developers will only build luxury.” He says new luxury units free up older, cheaper ones, and that Austin’s apartment boom has helped hold rents down.
Where it’s working
Sam says Washington State has gone the furthest, defining co-living in law and allowing it wherever six or more units can be built. He says Oregon passed something similar and that Colorado repealed occupancy limits on unrelated roommates. Texas did the same in college towns, and Sam wants it statewide next session. He says Florida and Virginia are looking at it, and Rhode Island’s version stalled in committee last session.
His take: this isn’t a partisan issue. States on both sides are looking at it.
How to help
Sam recommends two steps. The first is repealing occupancy limits on unrelated roommates. It’s a short bill and an easier political lift. The second is legalizing bigger co-living buildings and office conversions. Pacific Legal Foundation has the Golden Girls Act for the first step, and Sam has the Co-Living Buildings Act for the second.
If you want to help, show up at your city council and ask them to drop occupancy limits. We’ll feature these bills when sessions start and when good ones pass.
Follow Sam: ledgelawyer.com and his Substack, On the Ledge
Learn more and support the mission: https://LandLibertyMovement.org












